Consign with Us
Just send us the cards and we handle everything.
We’ll intake your cards, identify the correct series and parallels, research recent sales, and handle the entire listing and fulfillment process.
No Listing Fees! We payout twice a month via PayPal or Venmo.
| Sale Price | Payout |
|---|---|
| Under $200 | 80%* |
| $200–$500 | 90%* |
| $500+ | 95%* |
* Payout percentages are calculated after a 13.5% platform fee.
Choose how you want to sell:
Sell on WNYConsign.com
Want to maximize your return? We’ll list your cards at a fair market price based on recent comps and give them time to find the right buyer.
Instant eBay Auctions
Want your cards sold quickly? We can send them straight to eBay starting at $.99 and let the market determine the price.
To keep things efficient for everyone, we typically accept:
• Individual cards valued around $8 or more
• Small to large collections totaling $500-$2,000 in value
• Raw cards, graded cards and desirable modern or vintage singles
Due to our current workload, we are not accepting new consignors at this time. If you’re interested in consigning with us in the future, please complete the form below to join our waiting list. We’ll reach out as openings become available.